Thursday, March 19, 2009

Pascal Leclaire or Antoine Vermette?


We are closing in on the regular sesason, and the Jackets are pushing for a playoff spot. I want to revisit the trade that sent out an incredible young goalie for some more offense.  

First question, Which player would help out more getting to and winning in the playoffs?
That's and easy one, my first thought is how can a backup goalie help us out more than another big offensive threat? Then I thought won't Mason need any rest should we make it past the first round? But then I realized that Leclaire only won 4 games for the Jackets in 12 starts this season, before getting injured. Not great numbers, considering backup Wade Dubielewicz played above average last year replacing the often injured Rick Dipietro. Wade has started 3 games this season, and could very well play one game in the playoffs without having to many scares in net. So yes, the Jackets can easily go into the playoffs with Mason being backed up be Dubielewicz. So far, Vermette has been outstanding since his start with Columbus. In his 6 games with the Jackets he has 3 goals and 3 helpers, not to mention the OT winner last night against Chicago. In the post-season if you cant score you can't win. Vermette adds that extra push of offense for the Jackets in the post-season, which is far more important than a backup goalie. 

Second question, which team made a better move for the future?
Vermette has one more year on his contract after this year. Assuming the Jackets can resign him to a long-term contract, he will add another offensive threat to the Jacket line-up for years to come. Leclaire will have two years left in Ottawa after this season. Next year he will compete for the Senator starting goalie job, barring other goalie acquisitions, he has a very high chance of staring in Ottawa next year. Both players are 26, and both players have bright NHL careers ahead of them. However I see Vermette helping out Columbus more than Leclaire will help out Ottawa. Ever since Ottawa lost Patrick Lalime, they have gone threw so many different goalies, and I truely believe Leclaire will just become another victim of Ottawa misplaying and mistreating their goalies. 

Please post your thoughts, I would love to hear your opinion!

No comments:

Post a Comment